With stories
circulating about the British government stockpiling food,
as part of a plan to cover the eventuality of a no deal Brexit, there is talk
that the UK should become more self-sufficient in food once we leave the
European Union (EU). Of course all this would take time, certainly longer than by
our exit from the EU, which will happen in eight months’ time. But as a longer
term objective, this would surely be a sensible thing to do. It would avoid
tailbacks at ports and environmentally concerned people should welcome it, too.
But is it feasable?
Britain has not been self-sufficient in food since the
eighteenth century (when all of Ireland was included), and even then some foods
were imported. During world war two the country was close to being
self-sufficient in food, but rationing was introduced in 1940 and didn’t fully
end until 1954. Some lessons might be learned from some of the practices employed,
especially making more land available for farming, from this emergency period.
According
to the UK government’s figures, in 2016, Britons consumed only
49% of the total food and drink consumed in this country, from UK food sources. Of the other 51%, by far the biggest imports (30%) came
from the EU. Some of the food produced in the UK is of course exported, but
this only amounts to about 25% of the total produced. So, even if we stopped
exporting food, we would still have about a quarter of what is needed to make
up. The trade deficit in food, feed and drink increased in 2016 to £22.2
billion, up from £20.9 billion in 2015.
So replacing this amount of imported food would take some
doing, but I think it is possible to get close to it. It will require a massive
restructuring of UK farming in particular though, but it would also need a
complete change in the culture surrounding food consumption, from the British
people themselves. We have become so used to getting unseasonal food when we
want it, and have long had a taste for fruit, tea and coffee, that is difficult
to grow naturally in the British climate.
Agriculture in the UK uses 69% of the country's land
area, (43 million acres) but this includes land used for growing biofuels. It
is certainly possible, with the will, to increase this amount land with more
small holdings, in cities and towns, and people could be encouraged grow their
own food in gardens and allotments. Organic farming in Cuba
has moved in this direction since the collapse of the USSR, when chemicals and
pesticides stopped being provided to Cuban farmers.
Britain is an island of course, and so has access to
fishing, and we don’t eat nearly enough locally caught fish at the moment. But
people’s tastes have moved towards warmer water fish, like tuna and monkfish,
myself included. There would certainly be extra capacity in UK off shore
fishing, but will people want to eat it? In world war two just about the only
food that wasn’t rationed, was fish and chips, but people got fed up with
rationing generally. That was over sixty years ago, and much has changed in
food fashions since then.
There is no doubt, that a vegan, vegetarian,
pescatarian or even low meat diet would make food self-sufficiency much easier
to achieve. Beef and dairy farming especially is an unproductive use of farming
land. But again, the popular food culture of Big Macs etc, make for a huge
barrier to reducing the demand for beef products.
With the average age of a farm owner now 59, and with
the difficulties getting crop pickers etc as we leave the EU, it doesn’t look
as though the British like farming much anyway.
I can’t see why we couldn’t be more self-sufficient while
remaining within the EU, since we sell off 30% of our fishing quota to all
bidders now, for example. Brexit may well force this issue onto the agenda
though, but is self-sufficiency in food the likely outcome? I have to say I
think not, at least in the medium term. People want things to carry on exactly
as they have done. The demand will be filled mainly from North America, Australia
and New Zealand, (probably with lower hygiene standards) rather than
from our closest neighbours, Ireland, France and the Netherlands, as currently.
There is no reason why ecosocialists and greens should
not campaign for more food self-sufficiency, but we should at least recognise
that it is a mountain to climb, mainly because of the British people’s prevailing
cultural attitudes to food. It would be easier to keep our existing
arrangements with the EU, but that may not be possible.